Four classics that nearly ended up with different singers

Every so often you’re reminded that some of the biggest songs of the 70s and 80s were only a hair’s breadth away from being someone else’s signature tune. A demo gets parked, a contract gets in the way, or a band simply changes its mind, and pop history takes a different turn.

Take The Boys of Summer, a Rewind regular that still sounds like late night radio on an endless road. The music started with Heartbreakers guitarist Mike Campbell, who sketched it out over a drum machine while Tom Petty and the band were working around the Long After Dark era. Petty and producer Jimmy Iovine decided it wasn’t for that record, so Campbell tweaked the chords and brought it to Don Henley. Henley added the lyrics and it became the lead single from his 1984 album Building the Perfect Beast.

Hard Luck Woman has a similar sliding doors feel, only this time it stayed in house. Paul Stanley wrote it with Rod Stewart in mind, aiming for that raspy, story song style. Then Beth took off, with drummer Peter Criss on lead vocals, and KISS saw an opportunity. Criss sang Hard Luck Woman with a touch of Stewart in the delivery, and it went out as the lead single from 1976’s Rock and Roll Over, later reaching number 15 on the Billboard Hot 100.

Because the Night was born in the middle of Bruce Springsteen’s intense writing run ahead of Darkness on the Edge of Town, but it didn’t make the final cut. With Jimmy Iovine producing both Springsteen’s sessions and Patti Smith’s Easter, the song found a new destination. Springsteen and Iovine agreed Smith needed a standout hit, so the track was handed over and Smith completed it with her own lyrics. Springsteen eventually released his version decades later on 2010’s The Promise, drawing from the same pool of Darkness era material.

And then there’s Call Me, Blondie’s sleek, neon lit smash from the American Gigolo soundtrack. It wasn’t initially lined up for Debbie Harry at all. The plan was to have Stevie Nicks record it, but a label contract with Modern Records meant she couldn’t take part. The song was offered to Blondie instead, and Harry turned it around quickly, writing the lyrics in a matter of hours. It went on to top the Billboard Hot 100 for six weeks and became the band’s biggest hit.

For Irish listeners, all four of these tracks have long since found their way into the fabric of radio here, the kind of songs that still stop you mid sentence when they come on. They might have had different names on the sleeve, but the versions we know are the ones that stuck.

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
LinkedIn
On Key

Related Posts