Classic Rock Riffs That Sparked Borrowing Rows

With just a handful of keys and the same familiar chord shapes sitting under every guitarist’s fingers, rock music has always lived in that grey area between influence and imitation. Most of the time it’s a nod, a wink, or simply two writers landing on a similar idea. But every so often, a riff comes along that feels a little too close for comfort, and that’s when the accusations start flying and lawyers get mentioned.

One of the more obvious sound alike moments turns up between Cheap Trick and Poison. Cheap Trick’s She’s Tight arrived in 1982 as the band leaned into a shinier, radio friendly 80s sound. Five years later, Poison opened Talk Dirty To Me with a riff that’s hard to hear without thinking of Cheap Trick’s earlier track. Poison’s song went on to become a major hit, reaching number 9 on the Billboard Hot 100, while Cheap Trick never took legal action. The only courtroom drama came much later, when a Chicago group called Kid Rocker claimed they’d written the song first and sued Poison in 2011. That case was thrown out as baseless.

Then there’s the long running debate around the opening of Stairway To Heaven, a song Rewind listeners know inside out. Led Zeppelin had crossed paths with Spirit on the US circuit in 1968 and 1969, even opening for them on Zeppelin’s first American tour, and at one stage they reportedly played Spirit’s Fresh Garbage live. Spirit’s 1968 instrumental Taurus features an arpeggiated figure that many people hear echoed in Stairway, released in 1971 on Led Zeppelin IV. A copyright case was filed in 2014, with Jimmy Page arguing that the underlying progression was something musicians have used for years. Ultimately, a jury sided with Zeppelin, finding the introductions not distinctive enough to amount to infringement.

The Nirvana comparison is less about courtrooms and more about musical chat that refuses to go away. Smells Like Teen Spirit has often been lined up against Boston’s More Than A Feeling, which came out roughly two decades earlier. There’s never been an official link between the two songs, but Nirvana did lean into the conversation onstage at the 1992 Reading Festival, briefly teasing Boston’s tune before launching into Teen Spirit, as if to acknowledge what people were saying without taking it too seriously.

And finally, a metal moment that has resurfaced more than once over the years. Los Angeles band Excel started out in punk before shifting toward thrash on their 1989 album The Joke’s On You, which included Tapping Into The Emotional Void. When Metallica released Enter Sandman in 1991, listeners noticed similarities between the riffs, and Excel even weighed up legal action around 2003 before deciding not to proceed. The claim was pushed back into the spotlight again in 2025 when it was raised publicly by former Metallica guitarist and Megadeth frontman Dave Mustaine.

Whatever side you fall on with the borrowing debate, it’s a reminder that a great riff can travel a long way, sometimes further than its original writer ever expected.

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
LinkedIn
On Key

Related Posts